So I had the chance to review the newmans own organic dog lines we tried out 4 different things. The soft food, hard food and 2 treats. One was the Natural Peanut butter treats and another was their snake sticks that similar to beef jerky. So, I put together a small bowl with all of the different products and fed it to Roxy(My dog) and let her eat she ate all of the soft food first, then she ate the hard food and snack stick I noticed she put the peanut butter treats to the side and at the very end she ate them both! I love the food we had a dog get attacked and he wouldn’t eat anything and when I came over with this food he ate it right away! I was so surprised! This food saved him! Because he wasn’t eating anything! We love it and you will too!